| Author | Message |
JetSki
249 posts |
#119154 2008-05-13 18:34 GMT |
|
|
|
NeverAlone
268 posts |
#119155 2008-05-13 18:38 GMT |
|
if it is a sin, and muslim are not allowed to sin, then halal is going to be a paradox for them
|
|
LoneWolf
273 posts |
#119156 2008-05-13 18:38 GMT |
|
yes. thou shall not kill.
|
|
AgeingNature
290 posts |
#119157 2008-05-13 18:40 GMT |
|
Well, in the Crusades, the Christians were allowed to kill the Muslims to get RID of your sins.
|
|
IntoTheTrees
266 posts |
#119158 2008-05-13 18:42 GMT |
|
Context is everything. Whose god, and killing what or whom?
|
|
Bambi
265 posts |
#119159 2008-05-13 18:46 GMT |
|
any killing is a sin. . .well i think it is.
|
|
sorrowandsadness
244 posts |
#119160 2008-05-13 18:47 GMT |
|
Yes because God said your not allowed to kill no matter what. oh and the thing with the crusades was that preists said you would go straight to heaven if you died in combat and if you lived they gave you land and stuff just so you would go fight for them.
|
|
SilentHunter
264 posts |
#119161 2008-05-13 18:53 GMT |
|
chris is right, people eat meat all the time..is killing an animal a sin? I may be atheist, but every religion is different and has different standards.
|
|
ConverseShoesRule
265 posts |
#119162 2008-05-13 18:53 GMT |
|
In today's world the only ones who are killing in the name of God are Muslims.
Therefore you are asking if a Muslim can ever be justified in killing for a noble cause. The answer any Muslim will tell you is "Yes", this is possible. When he is defending Islam or when he is defending the weak from oppression, then the Muslim can kill in the name of Allah, in fact he is compelled to do so. |
|
Piramidy
267 posts |
#119163 2008-05-13 18:56 GMT |
|
No.. ignorant.. There is no "god" - or deity.
|
|
FeelingHot
257 posts |
#119164 2008-05-13 19:00 GMT |
|
what about just a killing? Without any justifications?what about killing in the name of man made Law? Lets those without sin will trow the stone first....next question: would the One Without sin trow the stone? I can't imagine a Saint trowing stone in order to kill...Would you? Killing is a killing even a doctor would miss a mark while performing its duty...Who is a Judge? It is not possible to know and calculate everything..Oh it would be justified, given different name, put under another Law...Actually our current justice is all about...
|
|
MexicanMug
273 posts |
#119165 2008-05-13 19:15 GMT |
|
no matter what killing is a sin any way.GOD can kill any body why he has to ask some body else to kill for him .it is so stupid.thanks.
|
|
Highclimber
251 posts |
#119166 2008-05-13 19:33 GMT |
|
Yes. Aside from the morality of killing, as regards the morality of using God's name to do it:
'Tis sweet, sweet poison to say "Thus saith the Lord" after one's own opinions. |
|
RacoonClingon
234 posts |
#119167 2008-05-13 22:15 GMT |
|
Bible translators have been attempting to do that for centuries.
|
|















